Comments on: MLB Vintage World Series Films – Cincinnati Reds 1975, 1976 & 1990 Reviews

By: Robert L. Simpson

Robert L. Simpson — Thu, 24 Jun 2010 22:03:42 +0000

Review by Robert L. Simpson for MLB Vintage World Series Films - Cincinnati Reds 1975, 1976 & 1990 Rating: You don't have to live in Cincinnati to enjoy this bit of history. The '75 game may go down as one of the best ever! Just a great piece of nostalgia for baseball fans

By: R. Williams

R. Williams — Thu, 24 Jun 2010 21:10:58 +0000

Review by R. Williams for MLB Vintage World Series Films - Cincinnati Reds 1975, 1976 & 1990 Rating: I was a big fan of the BRM when I was a tyke. I almost gave this a 4 because it does not do that team justice: they were one of the greatest teams ever, and frankly, at the very end of the original era in baseball: as the new series "The Bronx is on Fire" shows, the very next year, free agent reality created the age of the team of hessians. There's a sense in watching this of not really getting how these guys were so good that they just completely blew out the Yankees in 1976. Having grown up through the 75, Gowdy 'we was robbed' nonsense (that apparently cost him his job, and Snyder doing it on the news in NY), it was good to see them frame the series as a great battle and quote Fisk even as saying he was honored to play in Game 6.

It is great that quality stuff like this is available for so little money. I am going to look for some stuff that is more in depth, though.

By: Joseph R. Wenzel

Joseph R. Wenzel — Thu, 24 Jun 2010 20:41:12 +0000

Review by Joseph R. Wenzel for MLB Vintage World Series Films - Cincinnati Reds 1975, 1976 & 1990 Rating: I was a big fan of the Reds in the 70's. This DVD is a major disappointment. It is full of too close shots of players swinging the bat and Joe G. telling you what happened - you don't actually see it. Most of the game shots are of a player running or swinging the bat. Very few actual plays are shown. Most home runs are shown with a close-up of a player swinging and then a cut to the outfielder looking over the wall. It almost felt like they didn't have the real game action and were cutting the story together from clips they had. All in all it doesn't capture any of the excitement of the 75 series. One of the best ever. 76 is much of the same.